Stories & Reviews
Guestbook
“ This nice pizza place near Madison Square Garden in New York was recommended via reviews. I'm glad I listened because the pizza there is unique and delicious. They sell mostly pizza slices and calzones, but can accommodate whole pies. I recommend. ”
“ was really good — fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cheesy! Carnegie Pizza is just about a 5-minute walk from Times Square, making it a convenient stop if you’re exploring the area. They also have a couple of vegetarian options, which is great to see. Bonus tip: if you pay in cash, they offer a 3.7% discount. Overall, a solid spot for a quick and tasty New York slice! ”
“ Great pizza. The slice was $4-$5, but the sauce had great flavor. The crust had a nice crunch and good chewiness, and there was a good amount of cheese. Classic New York slice, simple and satisfying. ”
“ This is a great place to stop and grab a slice. The slices are about 4.50 for a plain slice, which is reasonable considering it is Times Square. I didn't care to see suggested 25% 30% and higher gratuity for picking up my food at the counter. That is a bit over the top. I also ordered garlic knots, which weren't bad but not the best that I've had. There is no parking, so forget that. I did see two families eating, so it should be OK to take your kids. The guys making the pizza work hard, and you do get piping hot pizza. So for that reason, I would recommend this pizzaria. ”
“ We tasted four different pizzas (both vegetarian and meat pizzas). Pizzas were ok, though the crust was a bit too crispy for our liking. They have huge variety of pizzas, also vegetarian options! While it wasn't the best pizza we've had in NYC, it's good quick option if you're in the area. The service was friendly, but the dining area (the tables and chairs) could have been a bit cleaner. We could still come back again if we would be nearby and need quickly something to eat! ”
Menu
Plain Cheese
Any Two Topping Pie
US$37.00Glass Soda
US$4.00Bottled Soda
US$3.50Bottled Water
US$2.50
About the Place
Carnegie Pizza
Welcome to Carnegie Pizza, a delightful pizza destination nestled conveniently near Madison Square Garden in New York City. Known for its quick service and delectable slices, Carnegie Pizza offers both locals and tourists a chance to indulge in a quintessential New York experience. Just a five-minute stroll from Times Square, this pizzeria has quickly become a go-to spot for those craving authentic, flavorful pizza.
As you step into Carnegie Pizza, you immediately sense the vibrant energy of the city, coupled with an inviting atmosphere perfect for grabbing a quick bite. The main highlights here are their signature pizza slices and calzones, though the option for whole pies is also available. Customers rave about the fresh ingredients, with each slice showcasing a crispy crust that has just the right amount of chewiness. One review noted the “great flavor” of the sauce, which is a testament to the care and craft that goes into each pizza preparation.
Vegetarians will be pleased to find a variety of options, a thoughtful touch that broadens the appeal of Carnegie Pizza. The slices are reasonably priced, especially for the bustling Times Square area, making it an attractive choice for budget-conscious pizza lovers. Regulars have shared that the cheesy goodness is a highlight, elevating each bite to a delightful experience.
Though the dining space is compact, it adds to the charm of the place. Guests appreciate the casual environment conducive to enjoying a quick meal before or after exploring the local attractions. It's a no-frills establishment that delivers on taste without unnecessary pomp. The friendly service complements the ambiance, turning a simple pizza stop into a gratifying culinary retreat.
However, it’s worth noting that Carnegie Pizza's appeal lies not just in the pizza itself but also in the vibrant company it keeps. The lively discussions and laughter that fill the air seem to enhance the flavors of what’s being served. Diners frequently mention their recommendations, just as Rayed Kury did when he urged newcomers to savor the unique offerings. Compliments about the variety offered, from classic toppings to innovative combinations, resonate with many who seek both familiarity and adventure in their pizza choices.
In conclusion, Carnegie Pizza stands tall as a solid contender in New York's competitive pizza landscape. With its commendable slices, welcoming vibe, and prime location, it’s a perfect pit stop for anyone wanting to enjoy a true taste of New York City. Next time you find yourself in the heart of Manhattan, don’t miss the opportunity to experience Carnegie Pizza—where every slice tells a story.
Plan Your Visit